Have you fished at Butterfield Lake? Be the first to comment on this fishing spot.
Fishing opportunities on Butterfield Lake in New York. Primary species includes; * Largemouth Bass * Smallmouth Bass * Northern Pike * Black Crappie * Bluegill * Brown Bullhead * Yellow Perch Approximately 45 minutes above Watertown, up interstate 81 with a short jump over on route 37 up to Redwood, NY.